Biden Administration Asks Supreme Court Not to Take Up ‘Insular’ Citizenship Cases
Biden Administration Asks Supreme Court Not to Take Up ‘Insular’ Citizenship Cases

By Naveen Athrappully

The Biden administration has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to pass over the opportunity to overrule a series of century-old rulings called “Insular Cases.”

Insular Cases deny residents of U.S. territories full constitutional rights by stating that the Constitution applies in full to incorporated territories and only in part to unincorporated territories. In a brief filed on Monday (pdf) in response to the Fitisemanu v. United States case, U.S. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar argued that the lawsuit would make a poor vehicle to reexamine Insular Cases.

The case, filed by John Fitisemanu, Pale Tuli, and Rosavita Tuli, challenges the denial of citizenship rights to residents of U.S. territories. The three individuals have been refused American citizenship as they were born in American Samoa, an unincorporated territory of the United States.

In the brief, Prelogar argued that the “ordinary tools of constitutional interpretation—including text, context, historical practice, and precedent—establish that the term ‘the United States’, as used in that provision, does not include American Samoa.”

“The multi-step framework from the Insular Cases is therefore beside the point. As a result, this case would be an unsuitable vehicle for reexamining those cases—cases which, petitioners emphasize, did not apply the Citizenship Clause.”

The administration is arguing that the court must not take up the case as the Legislature of American Samoa is not in favor of U.S. citizenship for its people. The American Samoan Legislature has passed a unanimous resolution stating that they oppose imposing American citizenship on them without consent.

In the government brief, Prelogar says that any court decision to accept the petitioner’s invitation to hold that the Citizenship Clause applies U.S. citizenship to all people born in American Samoa would “eliminate the opportunity for the American Samoan people to consider the issue democratically.”

Criticizing Insular Cases

Supreme Court Justices at both ends of the ideological spectrum have criticized the rulings of the Insular Cases, signaling that there might be widespread support to overrule them.

“A century ago in the Insular Cases, this Court held that the federal government could rule Puerto Rico and other Territories largely without regard to the Constitution,” Neil Gorsuch, a Trump appointee, wrote in a concurring opinion on Nov. 9, 2021 (pdf).

“It is past time to acknowledge the gravity of this error and admit what we know to be true: The Insular Cases have no foundation in the Constitution and rest instead on racial stereotypes. They deserve no place in our law,” the opinion said. Justice Sonia Sotomayer, who leans left, has also criticized Insular Cases.

The government’s stance has come under criticism from several human rights organizations. In a statement, David Cole, national legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union called the U.S. solicitor general’s decision to oppose overruling Insular Cases something that “simply cannot be squared with the values that underlie our Constitution, or for that matter, those professed by the Biden-Harris Administration.”

The court is presently in summer recess. It is expected to return to the bench on Oct. 3.

Affiliate News Feeds

  • Reuters
  • Washington Examiner
  • The Federalist
  • The Epoch Times
  • The Guardian
  • The Gateway Pundit
  • Judicial Watch

By Hans Mahncke News Analysis Late on Dec. 2, Elon Musk started the process of releasing thousands of internal Twitter emails. Musk, whose purchase of Twitter was completed on Oct. 28, had previously announced… [...]

By Naveen Athrappully France is banning short-haul domestic flights when there is a regular and frequent train option that takes less than two and a half hours, after a 2021 climate law, No… [...]

By Katabella Roberts House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) vowed on Sunday that the fiscal 2023 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) will not move forward unless the military’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate ends. Speaking on Fox Business Network’s “Sunday… [...]

California lawmakers are once again poised to introduce legislation to tax Big Oil despite public backlash over a similar move earlier this year. [...]

The Supreme Court heard oral arguments Monday in a case about whether a custom webpage designer who disagrees with LGBT marriage can refuse to create a website for a same-sex… [...]

President Joe Biden is considering the idea of removing the COVID-19 vaccination mandate for U.S. service members, though he backs Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin’s continued support for the measure. [...]

Even corrupt corporate media are willing to acknowledge the risk of nuclear war is 'now a daily issue for the Biden administration.' [...]

A legal rep for the Loudoun County School Board engaged in witness tampering during an investigation into an alleged sexual assault. [...]

The attack on Lorie Smith is both authoritarian and unconstitutional. [...]

A recently discovered filing in a court case relating to Big Tech censorship revealed that the office of Arizona Secretary of State Katie Hobbs coordinated with Twitter to censor election… [...]

The Biden administration has claims it drained the heavily depleted U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) in order to save the “global economy.” The White House’s International Energy Affairs adviser, Amos… [...]

To some, it’s an arcane discussion among constitutional scholars that reads like cement. To others, it’s a brazen grab for “runaway legislative power” by state lawmakers who say the U.S.… [...]

Labour-endorsed study finds initiative would save families thousands of pounds, cut benefits spending and raise tax revenuesFree universal preschool childcare and more funding for after-school clubs could increase government revenues… [...]

Union recommends members reject latest offer and adds 24-27 December strike but drops overtime ban Hopes of a deal to avert severe Christmas rail disruption were dashed on Monday night… [...]

PM caves in as up to 100 Tory MPs threaten to rebel, leading Labour to accuse him of putting party before countryRishi Sunak is to drop compulsory housebuilding targets to… [...]

Senator-elect Eric Schmitt, and current Missouri Attorney General, joined Sean Hannity on Monday night to discuss the federal government’s collusion with Democrat politicians to silence their conservative opposition. Currently, Missouri… [...]

It has been three weeks since four University of Idaho students were stabbed to death in a shared house near the campus and police still have not identified a suspect.… [...]

Kari Lake told Tucker Carlson on Monday night following the 2020 Arizona midterm election for governor that was awarded to Katie Hobbs. Previously, Tucker Carlson told Kari Lake that the… [...]

Top Headlines of the Week Press Releases Judicial Watch: Secret Service Has Repeatedly Changed Story on Existence of Hunter Biden Gun Records Judicial Watch announced recently that the United States… [...]

From The European Conservative: In recent days, we have seen news reports proclaiming the Ukrainian victory along the western bank of the Dnipro River in the city of Kherson. These… [...]

Secret Service Repeatedly Changes Its Story on Hunter Biden Gun Records What is the Secret Service Hiding about Biden Raid on Trump’s Home? Judicial Watch Sues to Find Out! Judicial… [...]


USNN World News (USNN) USNN World News Corporation is a media company consisting of a series of sites specializing in the collection, publication and distribution of public opinion information, local,...