Judge: Government Hasn’t Proven Trump Search Warrant Affidavit Should Remain Sealed
Judge: Government Hasn’t Proven Trump Search Warrant Affidavit Should Remain Sealed

By Zachary Stieber

U.S. government officials have not presented sufficient evidence to keep a key document related to the search warrant executed at former President Donald Trump’s home shielded from the public, a federal judge ruled on Aug. 22.

U.S. officials have claimed that an affidavit, which convinced U.S. Magistrate Judge Bruce Reinhart to approve the warrant, needs extensive redactions to protect FBI agents and witnesses, as well as the ongoing investigation into Trump.

The redactions would leave “very little—nothing of substance,” Jay Bratt, chief of the Department of Justice’s Counterintelligence and Export Control Section, told Reinhart during a recent hearing.

The government has met its burden of showing its interests outweigh public access to unsealing the entire affidavit, Reinhart said in the new ruling. But the government has not yet sufficiently argued that portions of the document should not be made public.

“I cannot say at this point that partial redactions will be so extensive that they will result in a meaningless disclosure, but I may ultimately reach that conclusion after hearing further from the Government,” he said.

Still, “given the intense public and historical interest in an unprecedented search of a former President’s residence, the Government has not yet shown that these administrative concerns are sufficient to justify sealing,” he added. “I therefore reject the Government’s argument that the present record justifies keeping the entire Affidavit under seal.”

Reinhart ordered the government to file additional evidence supporting keeping the entire document under seal along with proposed redactions to the affidavit, which is a document authored by an FBI agent that outlines why the government believes it needs a warrant. The warrant was served on Aug. 8 at Mar-a-Lago in Palm Beach, Florida.

Reinhart will review the proposed redactions. He’ll either reject them while giving the government a chance to appeal to a higher court or agree with them and release the redacted document.

Legal Principles

The public has a right to view judicial proceedings and records, based on the U.S. Constitution’s First Amendment and common law, but that right is not absolute. In some cases, a party may be able to show that other interests outweigh the public interest. The government and other parties agreed on the release of the warrant itself and some other material, but have diverged on the affidavit.

U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) lawyers have said that the government’s investigation and the consequences for individuals who were cited in the affidavit outweigh any public right of access.

On the other side, nonprofits and media outlets say factors like the immense public interest in the case and the details that have been leaked to outlets support making the affidavit public, even if some parts of it are redacted.

Lawyers for Trump have not formally asked the judge to release the affidavit. The former president and his counsel have said in public statements that the document should be released with no redactions.

Reinhart’s Thinking

The judge appeared to align with the government on worries that releasing the affidavit would help identify agents and others involved in the case.

Reinhart said he gives “great weight” to the “significant likelihood that unsealing the Affidavit would harm legitimate privacy interests by directly disclosing the identity of the affiant as well as providing evidence that could be used to identify witnesses,” which could then lead to the investigation being impeded through witness intimidation.

He also said he agreed with DOJ officials that the affidavit disclosures the sources and methods that are being used in the investigation, and that the law requires the information to be shielded from the public.

And he also said he was considering how the affidavit discusses details of Mar-a-Lago, a location protected by U.S. Secret Service agents because a former president resides there.

All three factors weigh in favor of keeping the affidavit sealed, the judge said.

The only other factor Reinhart cited as having “great weight” was how the warrant is of significant concern to the public.

“Certainly, unsealing the Affidavit would promote public understanding of historically significant events. This factor weighs in favor of disclosure,” the judge said.

Reinhart also took on the argument that because many alleged details of the raid have been reported by news outlets, the affidavit should be unsealed.

“No one disputes that there has been much public discourse about this Warrant and the related investigation. Nevertheless, much of the information being discussed is based on anonymous sources, speculation, or hearsay; the Government has not confirmed its accuracy,” he said, adding later that the arguments “ignore” how the affidavit goes over the government’s sources and methods.

Reinhart said he remains confident that the information in the affidavit is reliable, so releasing it would not “cause false information to be disseminated,” and that no evidence has emerged so far to indicate the nonprofits and outlets seeking the records are doing so “for any illegitimate purpose.”

Affiliate News Feeds

  • Reuters
  • Washington Examiner
  • The Federalist
  • The Epoch Times
  • The Guardian
  • The Gateway Pundit
  • Judicial Watch

By Naveen Athrappully NASA announced on Tuesday that it intends to cancel the development of its GeoCarb mission, which was proposed to be a low-cost satellite aimed at monitoring greenhouse gas… [...]

By Bryan Jung The rate of job cuts in the United States soared 127 percent in November, amid a wave of layoffs in the tech industry. The American employers announced 76,835 cuts… [...]

By Jennifer Margulis and Joe Wang What medicine should you take? How should you treat any given illness? What preventative measures are most effective for you? Which vaccines do you need? These… [...]

A former professor at the University of California San Diego said she gave all of her students "A" grades and no homework in a recently unearthed video. [...]

A key Senate vote over whether to provide paid sick leave for rail workers is highlighting a divide within the GOP, a party that has increasingly tried to position itself… [...]

Transmission infrastructure will need to double or triple to accommodate the growth. [...]

Anyone still wearing a face mask to protect himself from Covid probably has no intention of ever shedding it now. [...]

Anyone who actually watched 'Wednesday' can see that the 'racism' accusations are ridiculous and performative. [...]

Chuck DeVore's historical fiction book 'Crisis of the House Never United: A Novel of Early America' demonstrates not only why procedure and patience matter, but also the genius of the… [...]

The head of the largest oil and natural gas trade association warned that failure to replenish the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) could trigger another oil crisis in the coming… [...]

This episode will premiere on Friday, Dec. 2 at 8 p.m. ET. In this episode of Kash’s Corner, we discuss the impending release of the Jan. 6 committee’s final report.… [...]

New York’s quest to replace the troubled Rikers Island jail complex with smaller facilities across the five boroughs could lead to either hazardous overcrowding or the release of dangerous detainees,… [...]

Health Security Agency issues rare alert over rise in cases, urging people to seek immediate medical help if they see symptomsQ&A: what are the symptoms and how can strep A… [...]

Exclusive: Labour says ministers have been told repeatedly that people with prepayment meters are not getting enough supportCase studies: ‘I can’t afford to heat my son’s room’Up to half a… [...]

Group G match at Stadium 974 kicks off at 7pm GMTCameroon v Brazil – follow live with Scott MurrayShare your thoughts with Will via email or on TwitterThe national anthems… [...]

Joe Biden’s gender fluid “pup handler” DOE employee Sam Brinton was charged with felony theft for stealing a woman’s luggage last month at MSP airport in Minnesota. According to Alpha… [...]

By Wayne Allyn Root Let me start with a disclaimer. I’m a Jew. Not just any Jew. Ancestery.com tested my DNA and reported I’m 99.9% Eastern European Jewish ancestry. That’s… [...]

The Department of Homeland Security has issued a National Terrorism Advisory System Bulletin in advance of the holidays. The United States remains in a heightened threat environment. Lone offenders and… [...]

From Fox News: The Secret Service will not say why they changed their position regarding a government watchdog’s records request into Hunter Biden’s gun investigation records. Government watchdog Judicial Watch… [...]

(Washington, DC) – Judicial Watch announced today that the United States Secret Service has repeatedly changed its position about whether it is in possession of records related to the investigation… [...]

The Biden administration is giving a nonprofit partially funded by leftwing billionaire George Soros’s Open Society Foundations (OSF) $12 million to strengthen labor rights and empower workers in three Latin… [...]

USNN2020

USNN World News (USNN) USNN World News Corporation is a media company consisting of a series of sites specializing in the collection, publication and distribution of public opinion information, local,...