1.3 Million Jobs Were the Result of Double-Counting This Year, Says Heritage Economist
1.3 Million Jobs Were the Result of Double-Counting This Year, Says Heritage Economist

By Andrew Moran

The monthly U.S. jobs reports have topped market estimates many times this year. The July and August non-farm payrolls (NFP) reports showed 528,000 and 315,000 new jobs, respectively, higher than what many economists and analysts had initially projected.  

White House officials have taken victory laps on the employment data, noting that these numbers are proof the economy is strong and that President Joe Biden’s policies are supporting post-pandemic growth.  

But economists had questions about the discrepancy between the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data and the various labor-related numbers revealed throughout the month. Plus, why has the Federal Reserve’s quantitative tightening campaign failed to diminish labor demand?

Several experts might have determined what is causing better-than-expected labor numbers. The answer may have to do with double-counting.  

Is Double-Counting Hiding Labor Weakness?  

The NFP report contains the results of two surveys, the Establishment Survey and the Household Survey. The former measures employment, hours, and earnings through a sample of businesses. The latter gauges “the labor force status of the civilian noninstitutional population with demographic detail” using a sample of households.  

The key difference between these two surveys is the methodology, as the Establishment Survey allows for double-counting. In other words, it will identify multiple jobholders for every position, meaning that a person with two jobs will count for two jobs. But the Household Survey will only consider an individual with two jobs as one job.  

BLS researchers will also count someone shifting from self-employment to working for a company as a new position, despite the lack of net gains in employment.  

According to EJ Antoni, a research fellow for regional economics in the Center for Data Analysis at The Heritage Foundation, “There is considerable evidence that this double-counting has accelerated recently.”  

Antoni’s research found that of the 5.8 million jobs recovered in the last year, roughly 1.3 million were the result of double-counting. In the August numbers, double-counting accounted for 208,000 jobs.  

“Over the last year, a disproportionate number of people have taken second (or third) jobs and switched from self-employment to working for other businesses,” Antoni told The Epoch Times. “These changes in employment do not actually change the number of people with jobs, but they boost the headline jobs number from the establishment survey, one of two surveys which make up the monthly Employment Situation report from the Labor Department’s Bureau of Labor Statistics.”  

How the figures are put together should prompt analysts to adopt “a holistic view on the monthly report” rather than the headline numbers,” he added.  

Last month, the total number of multiple jobholders was a seasonally adjusted 7.747 million, and self-employed workers fell to 9.629 million.  

Mike Shedlock, a registered investment advisor for SitkaPacific Capital and author of the popular global economics blog MishTalk, also noted the trouble with how BLS gathers labor data.  

“In the household survey, if you work as little as one hour a week, even selling trinkets on eBay, you are considered employed,” he wrote. “In the household survey, if you work three part-time jobs, 12 hours each, the BLS considers you a full-time employee.”  

Moreover, other factors can distort the monthly labor report. For example, a common measurement is that if someone is out of work and fails to search for a job, he or she is described as having dropped out of the labor force rather than being listed as unemployed.  

“These distortions artificially lower the unemployment rate, artificially boost full-time employment, and artificially increase the payroll jobs report every month,” he said.  

What About Wage Growth?  

Many have championed accelerated wage growth over the last 18 months. In August, average hourly earnings held steady at 5.2 percent year over year, hitting $32.36. But inflation has eaten away at these gains.  

BLS data show that real average hourly earnings (inflation-adjusted) fell 2.8 percent. In addition, when real average hourly earnings are combined with the 0.6 percent drop in the average workweek, the figure is negative 3.4 percent.  

“The longer inflation and inflation expectations remain elevated, the higher and longer-lasting the pressures on wage growth are likely to be,” wrote Òscar Jordà, a senior policy advisor in the Economic Research Department of the Federal Reserve, in a recent paper.  

According to the Survey of Consumer Expectations (SCE) conducted by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, one-year ahead earnings growth expectations have remained flat, at 3 percent, since December 2021. In addition, consumer inflation expectations over the next year eased to 5.7 percent in August, after potentially peaking at 6.8 percent in June.

Affiliate News Feeds

  • Washington Examiner
  • The Federalist
  • The Epoch Times
  • The Guardian
  • The Gateway Pundit

CHANTILLY, Virginia — A group of roughly 70 students at Chantilly High School in northern Virginia marched out of class and off school grounds without adult supervision to protest Republican… [...]

President Joe Biden's plan to forgive hundreds of billions of dollars in student loan debt is facing its first serious legal challenge alleging it violates federal law and the Constitution,… [...]

As inflation weighs on the public, 71% of workers claimed their salary and wage growth is being outpaced by a rise in the cost of living. [...]

Historical setbacks and the proliferation of broken homes hurt black Americans, but there’s also something else: Marxism.  [...]

A woman’s death in Iran has sparked mass protests but little response from the Biden administration or ‘the squad’ of congresswomen. [...]

Ryan Busse claims to be a gun industry insider, but he has no interest in advocating for America's hunters and riflemen. [...]

A measure that would reform the Electoral Count Act of 1887 and make it harder for members of Congress to object to or decertify presidential election results has advanced in the… [...]

Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) on Monday highlighted the declining state of the economy under President Joe Biden and said he does not believe the passage of the Inflation Reduction Act is… [...]

A federal appeals court in Manhattan handed former President Donald Trump a procedural victory Tuesday in a defamation lawsuit, after famed columnist E. Jean Carroll claimed that Trump had raped… [...]

Bank’s emergency move brings relief to bond market, but fails to stabilise UK currencyOver here, chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng is due to meet bankers again today in an effort to calm… [...]

Labour leader says chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng must abandon mini-budget measures that prompted market turmoilQ: When would you get debt falling as a proprotion of GDP?Starmer says Labour does want to… [...]

We rate PM’s likely next steps as she sets about navigating path through crisis of her government’s makingBattered by financial markets and besieged by MPs whose constituents’ mortgage payments are… [...]

The days when Hollywood was just focused on providing entertainment have long gone. It is now overtaken by political correctness and “wokeness” from the left. This culture of “wokeness” and… [...]

GOP lawmakers are demanding Attorney General Merrick Garland justify why the FBI deployed dozens of fully-armed agents to raid Catholic pro-life activist Mark Houck as his “screaming” children watched the… [...]

Aerial view of blown Nord Stream pipeline near Bornholm Island. Guest post by Bill Hennessy Three deep-water explosions destroyed the Nord Stream pipelines under the Baltic Sea on Monday. While… [...]


USNN World News (USNN) USNN World News Corporation is a media company consisting of a series of sites specializing in the collection, publication and distribution of public opinion information, local,...